Steven Mather Solicitor
Steven MatherSolicitor
0116 3667 900

Commercial

Loan agreements, debentures and charges for private lending

Lending money to a company privately? I draft the loan agreement, debenture, charges and guarantees so you can get your money back, for a fixed fee.

Fixed fee from £1,500 plus VAT, agreed in writing before I start.

If you’re lending money to a business privately, rather than through a bank, I can draft the documents that go with it. That might be a shareholder or director lending to their own company, an investor funding a business or a property project, a business lending to a customer or supplier, or someone putting money into a joint venture. I draft the loan agreement and, where the loan is secured, the debenture, legal charges and personal guarantees that sit behind it.

I don’t act for banks or other institutional lenders, so I’m not conflicted out of acting on private loans. I act for one side only, which is usually the lender, but I also act for borrowers who need the lender’s documents reviewed, usually where the money is coming from a private lender rather than a bank or other mainstream lender.

What the loan agreement covers

The loan agreement sets out how much is being lent, whether it’s paid over in one go or in instalments, the interest, and when and how it’s repaid. It also needs to say what happens if things go wrong, which is the part that matters most if you ever need to rely on it. The events of default (non-payment, breach of the agreement, insolvency, a change in who owns the borrower and so on) let you demand the whole loan back early, and the agreement should say whether the loan falls due automatically when one of them happens or only when you serve a demand.

That choice can matter a great deal; in a recent Court of Appeal case a loan that fell due automatically on “the insolvency of the company” became repayable years before the lender realised, and by the time he sued it was too late (I’ve written about that case and what it means for guarantees).

If the money is being raised from several people on the same terms, loan notes may suit better than a series of separate agreements, and I’ve written about how loan notes work.

Taking security

An unsecured lender to a company that fails usually ranks behind the secured creditors and the preferential ones, and may get little or nothing back. Security improves that position, and for a private loan to a company it usually means a debenture, a legal charge over property, a charge over shares, or some combination of them.

A debenture gives you a fixed charge over particular assets of the company and a floating charge over everything else, such as its stock, debts and cash. If the company defaults, the debenture lets you appoint an administrator or a receiver to recover what you’re owed. A legal charge over property gives you security over a specific building or piece of land, which can be sold if the loan isn’t repaid. A charge over shares lets you take the shares in the borrowing company, or another company, if the loan isn’t repaid.

Any charge created by a company has to be registered at Companies House within 21 days of the date it’s created, under section 859A of the Companies Act 2006. If it isn’t registered in time, it’s void against a liquidator or administrator, which leaves you as an unsecured creditor in the insolvency. A charge over registered land also needs registering at HM Land Registry, and where a property is involved I’ll usually work with a Nexa property colleague on that side.

Personal guarantees

Where the borrower is a company, it’s common to ask the directors or shareholders to guarantee the loan personally, so that you can pursue them if the company can’t pay. A guarantee needs to be drafted with care, as guarantees are read strictly and a guarantor can be released by things the lender does later, such as agreeing to give the borrower more time or changing the terms of the loan without the guarantor’s consent. A well-drafted guarantee deals with that, and with whether the guarantor is liable as a principal debtor and under an indemnity as well as a guarantee. If you’re a director who has been asked to give a guarantee, I also give independent legal advice on what you’re signing.

Lending to individuals

I should say that if you’re lending to an individual rather than to a company, or the loan is secured on someone’s home, it may be regulated by the FCA as consumer credit or a regulated mortgage, and a lender who isn’t authorised can find that the loan can’t be enforced. I don’t advise on whether a loan is regulated, so if there’s any doubt you’ll need to take advice on that first.

Common terms

  • Loan agreement or facility agreement: the contract setting out how much is lent and the terms for drawing it, paying interest and repaying it. Banks tend to call it a facility agreement; I’ve written about what a facility agreement is.
  • Event of default: something listed in the loan agreement, such as non-payment or insolvency, which lets the lender demand the whole loan back early.
  • Debenture: a document in which a company gives a lender security over its assets, usually a fixed charge over some assets and a floating charge over the rest.
  • Fixed charge: security over a specific asset, which the company can’t sell or deal with without the lender’s consent.
  • Floating charge: security over a changing pool of assets, such as stock and cash, which the company can use in the ordinary course of business until the charge “crystallises” on a default or insolvency.
  • Legal charge: security over land or buildings, registered at HM Land Registry, which lets the lender sell the property if the loan isn’t repaid.
  • Personal guarantee: a promise by an individual, usually a director or shareholder, to pay the company’s debt if the company doesn’t.
  • Deed of priority: an agreement between lenders who both have security over the same assets, setting out who gets paid first. If the borrower already banks with a lender that has a debenture, you’ll usually need one.

Common questions

Who pays the legal costs? It’s common for the borrower to pay the lender’s legal costs, and that’s usually agreed when the terms of the loan are agreed and then written into the loan agreement. If I’m acting for the lender, the borrower paying my fee doesn’t make me the borrower’s solicitor.

Do I need a loan agreement if I’m lending to my own company? There’s no legal requirement, but without one it can be hard to show what was agreed, including whether the money was a loan at all, and that tends to matter most if the company runs into trouble or you want to sell it. A written agreement also lets you take security, which a director’s loan account on its own doesn’t give you.

Can we agree any interest rate we like? On a business loan the parties are largely free to agree the rate, but default interest that is out of proportion to the lender’s legitimate interest can be unenforceable as a penalty (I’ve written about a case on default interest), and there can be tax points on interest paid by a company to an individual, which your accountant should check.

Is a personal guarantee enough, or do I need security too? A guarantee is only as good as the guarantor’s ability to pay, so if the amount is significant it’s usually worth having both, and a debenture or legal charge also puts you ahead of the unsecured creditors if the company fails.

Will you register the charge? Yes, I can register a company’s charge at Companies House for you, but as the 21 days runs from the date the charge is created, I need the signed and dated documents back straight away.

What it costs

I work on fixed fees, agreed in writing before I start. A straightforward loan agreement starts at around £1,500 plus VAT, and the fee goes up where there’s a debenture, a legal charge, share security or guarantees from several people, or where the other side’s lawyers want to negotiate.

Next steps

If you’d like me to draft the documents, get in touch and send me the details of who is lending, who is borrowing, how much, the interest and repayment terms you’ve agreed, and what security or guarantees you have in mind. I’ll come back to you with a fixed fee and a scope of work.

Also in this section

Related writing

Where this goes wrong in practice

All writing

Swipe for more

Drop me a line

If you’re a business owner facing a legal problem, get in touch.

I’ll give you a steer and tell you whether I’m the right person for the job. If I’m not, I’ll say so and point you at someone who is.

Send me the detailsCall 0116 3667 900