Steven Mather Solicitor
Steven MatherSolicitor
0116 3667 900

Writing

Can giving a debtor more time to pay release the guarantor? Lessons from Dunn v Kazolides (2026)

Steven Mather··6 min read

Can giving a debtor more time to pay release the guarantor? It can, if you make a binding agreement with the debtor to give it more time, or otherwise change the arrangement the guarantor signed up to, without the guarantor’s consent, and the guarantee doesn’t say you’re allowed to. Simply holding off from chasing the money won’t usually release a guarantor, but agreeing new terms, even informally and even for good reasons, often will.

Most people who are owed money assume that being patient with the debtor can only help, and that the guarantee sits in the background until it’s needed. A Court of Appeal judgment handed down on 20 November 2026, Dunn v Kazolides [2026] EWCA Civ 1484, shows how that assumption can go wrong. Lord Justice Zacaroli gave the main judgment, with which Lady Justice Lieven and Lord Justice Lewison agreed, upholding the decision of Sharif Shivji KC, sitting as a deputy High Court judge, in 2025.

What happened

In 2006 Mr Dunn entered into a joint venture agreement to develop seven villas in Cyprus through a company owned by Mr Kazolides and Mr Stylianou. Mr Dunn lent the company the development money, eventually 800,000 Cypriot pounds plus whatever else was needed, secured by a charge over the property, and the two owners guaranteed the company’s obligations under the agreement. The company had to try to sell the villas as soon as practicable once development began, and the loan would become automatically repayable on various events, including “the insolvency of the Company”.

The development went badly, as the villas weren’t finished until 2010, and one was sold in 2018 and the other six in 2019, to a company connected with Mr Dunn, who had been a director of the company since 2009. He sued Mr Kazolides on the guarantee in March 2022, and lost.

Agreeing to give more time

Late in 2009, after the loan had already fallen due, Mr Dunn and the company reached an understanding that the villas wouldn’t be sold as soon as practicable but at a time, and a price, of Mr Dunn’s choosing. The trial judge found that this changed the company’s obligation to sell and gave it more time to repay the loan, and that Mr Kazolides hadn’t agreed to it.

Under the long-established rule in Holme v Brunskill, a guarantor is usually released if the creditor and the debtor vary the contract that was guaranteed, or the creditor makes a binding agreement to give the debtor time to pay, without the guarantor’s consent. The only exception is a change that is obviously insubstantial or that can only benefit the guarantor, and the court won’t hold an inquiry into whether the guarantor was actually worse off; the guarantor is entitled to decide for himself whether he’s prepared to stay liable on the new terms. Many guarantees exclude the rule by allowing the creditor to vary the arrangement or give time without releasing the guarantor, and the rule only applies where the guarantee doesn’t.

Mr Dunn argued that he had only held off from suing, which on its own doesn’t release a guarantor, as a creditor is entitled to be patient. The Court of Appeal rejected that. The company had given up its obligation to sell as soon as practicable, which benefited Mr Dunn directly, and that was enough to make his agreement to give it time binding. The court also rejected his argument that this only concerned his role as a director of the company, as the obligation to sell was in the joint venture agreement to which he was a party as lender.

I should say that the Court of Appeal didn’t strictly need to decide this point, as it had already found that the claim was out of time (explained below), and it dealt with it because the point had been fully argued. Its view isn’t binding in the way the main decision is, but it agreed with the trial judge, and the rule it applied has been settled law for well over a century.

When the loan fell due

The claim failed first on limitation. The guarantee claim arose when the company became liable to repay the loan, and the loan became repayable automatically on “the insolvency of the Company”. Mr Dunn argued that this meant a formal insolvency, or at most the company being unable to pay its debts as they fell due, but the Court of Appeal held that it also covered balance-sheet insolvency under section 123 of the Insolvency Act 1986. That doesn’t mean a snapshot of assets against liabilities on a particular day; it asks whether, allowing for future and contingent liabilities, the company can reasonably be expected to meet what it owes. By September 2009 the likely sale price of the finished villas wouldn’t cover the company’s debts, including Mr Dunn’s own loan, so the loan fell due then.

That put the claim out of time whether the limitation period was six years or the 12 years that applies to a deed under section 8 of the Limitation Act 1980. The court said that the balance-sheet test can be hard to apply in borderline cases, but that wasn’t a reason to read it out of the agreement, and Mr Dunn, as a director with a right to regular financial information, was well placed to see it coming.

If you hold a guarantee

If someone owes you money and a director, a shareholder or a parent company has guaranteed it, talk to the guarantor before you agree anything new with the debtor, whether that’s more time to pay, a payment plan, a change to the interest, a different timetable for selling an asset or a change to the security. Get the guarantor’s consent in writing, ideally in a short deed or letter confirming that the guarantee continues to apply to the arrangement as changed. This comes up for sellers owed deferred consideration that a buyer’s director has guaranteed (I’ve written about how the wording of a guarantee in a share purchase agreement can matter), for landlords with a rent guarantor, and for anyone who lends money into a joint venture.

When you take a guarantee in the first place, check that it lets you give time, vary the arrangement and release other security without discharging the guarantor, as most lenders’ standard forms do. If you’re on the other side and you’ve been asked to give a personal guarantee, those are the clauses that take away this protection, and they’re worth understanding before you sign; I’ve written about a director who tried three ways out of his personal guarantee.

Check the repayment triggers in any loan you make to a company. An automatic trigger such as “insolvency” can make the loan fall due on a date nobody notices at the time, and the time limit for suing runs from then. If you’d rather the loan fell due only on a formal event or when you serve a demand, the agreement needs to say so.

I draft joint venture agreements, loan agreements and guarantees for owner-managed businesses and the people who invest in them, and the guarantees that sit behind deferred consideration when a business is sold. I don’t run litigation myself; claims on guarantees go to my Nexa colleagues who handle contract disputes. Get in touch if you need some help.

Written by Steven Mather, a business solicitor acting on company sales and purchases. This is general information about the law, not legal advice on your situation. Law correct as at .

Keep reading

More on getting a sale right

All writing

Swipe for more

Drop me a line

If you’re a business owner facing a legal problem, get in touch.

I’ll give you a steer and tell you whether I’m the right person for the job. If I’m not, I’ll say so and point you at someone who is.

Send me the detailsCall 0116 3667 900