This case report is now 0 months old and may not represent current law.
Can a council publish your report under FOI with its own criticism attached? It probably can, if it publishes the report in full without changing it, as releasing the report is part of its duty under the Freedom of Information Act and a page of criticism added at the front is likely to be treated as comment on your work rather than a distortion of it. That’s what the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court decided last week, dismissing a consultancy’s claim against a London council for copyright infringement, derogatory treatment and false attribution.
The case is Aldaba Ltd v London Borough of Southwark [2026] EWHC 2920 (IPEC), decided by Miss Recorder Amanda Michaels, sitting as a deputy judge of the IPEC, on 12 November 2026 after a one-day trial. It’s a first instance decision which turned largely on the facts and on the wording of one contract, and the consultancy was represented by its director rather than by lawyers.
What happened
Southwark commissioned Aldaba, a management consultancy, to evaluate its scheme giving free school meals to more secondary school pupils (the press put the contract at £60,000). The contract said Aldaba would own the copyright in its work and gave the council a licence to use it for council business. It also had a clause on freedom of information requests, which said the council could disclose information, would consult Aldaba where reasonably practicable, and wouldn’t be liable for any loss caused by disclosure.
The council wasn’t happy with the drafts and sent comments, some of which Aldaba said arrived too late to deal with. The final report was delivered in September 2024 and the council paid in full and thanked Aldaba for it. A member of the public then asked for the report under the Freedom of Information Act, and in January 2025 the council released it with a watermark on every page saying “Released under information request” and an extra page, inserted between the cover and page 2, headed “Disclaimer”. That page said the council hadn’t accepted the report as final, that it contended the report contained factual inaccuracies and used inappropriate language and tone, but that it also contained some important recommendations.
Local papers picked it up and accused the council of trying to bury a report that criticised its scheme, and Aldaba sued for about £14,000.
Moral rights belong to the people who wrote the report
The main complaint was that the disclaimer was derogatory treatment of the report under section 80 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. That right belongs to the author, and under the Act an author is the person who creates the work, so it has to be an individual. Aldaba owned the copyright, as its employees had written the report in the course of their employment, but it wasn’t the author, and none of the individual authors had been named or joined to the claim, so the company couldn’t bring this part of the claim at all.
The judge went on to say that the claim would have failed anyway. Inserting the disclaimer between the cover and the contents was a “treatment” of the report, but it didn’t distort or mutilate it, as every word of the report was still there and the disclaimer was obviously the council’s comment rather than part of the report. The judge drew a distinction between distorting a work and criticising it, and said that if Aldaba’s real complaint was that the criticism was unfair, that was a matter for the law of defamation rather than copyright (no defamation claim was before the court). Aldaba had also produced very little evidence of its reputation, and the press articles it relied on blamed the council, not the consultancy, so there was no evidence of prejudice either.
The watermark was too trivial to count as a treatment at all, and the false attribution claim failed because no reasonable reader would think Aldaba had written the council’s disclaimer.
Copyright and the FOI clause
Aldaba also said that publishing the altered version infringed its copyright. The judge held that the clause in the contract on information requests authorised the council to publish the report in response to an FOI request, and that a failure to consult Aldaba first would at most be a breach of contract, which hadn’t been claimed. Separately, section 50 of the 1988 Act says that doing something specifically authorised by an Act of Parliament doesn’t infringe copyright, and the judge held that releasing the report with a disclaimer that commented on it, without changing any of its contents, was within the council’s duty under section 1 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000. Adding a watermark and a disclaimer also wasn’t an “adaptation” of the report, which in copyright law has a narrow meaning (a translation, for example).
What the claim was worth
Even if Aldaba had won on copyright, the judge said she would have awarded only nominal damages of £100. Aldaba had been paid in full, the report was specific to Southwark and had no real value to anyone else, and it would have received nothing more if the council had published the report without the disclaimer. She would not have awarded additional damages either, as the council had made no money from what it did and had a reasonable view that its contract allowed it. Costs were left to be dealt with on the usual IPEC basis.
If you write reports for clients
Most consultancy contracts leave the client free to use the report, and anything given to a public body can end up published under the Freedom of Information Act, so it’s sensible to assume that a report you deliver may become public, possibly with the client’s view of it attached. If that matters to you, the contract is the place to deal with it. You could ask for a right to be consulted before publication that has some consequence if it’s ignored, a right to have a short response published alongside any criticism, or an obligation on the client to publish the report only in full and without additions, although a public body can’t contract out of its FOI duties and may not agree to much.
Get acceptance of the final report in writing and in clear terms. The council here thanked Aldaba for the report and paid the final invoice, and then four months later said it had never accepted the report as final. Clear sign-off won’t stop a client criticising your work, but it would have made it much harder to say the report had never been accepted.
If your staff write the work, the moral rights belong to the individuals who wrote it and not to the company, so a company can’t bring a derogatory treatment claim in its own name.
I’d also say that this is perhaps a case where Aldaba, which was represented at trial by its director rather than by lawyers, may well have been wise to take legal advice, both when it entered into the contract with the council at the outset and later when the dispute arose. Advice at the start might have produced a contract that gave it more say over how the report was published, and advice once the council had published it would at least have flagged the problems with bringing the moral rights claim in the company’s name, and how little the claim was likely to be worth, before it went to a trial.
I advise on intellectual property and draft the contracts consultancies use with their clients, including the clauses on ownership, licences and publication. I don’t run IP litigation myself; those claims go to my Nexa colleagues who handle intellectual property disputes. Get in touch if you need some help.
Written by Steven Mather, a business solicitor acting on company sales and purchases. This is general information about the law, not legal advice on your situation. Law correct as at .



