This case report is now 0 months old and may not represent current law.
Do you have to pay the adjudicator if you think the decision was wrong? Almost certainly, if you signed his terms, as adjudicators’ terms usually make both parties liable for the fees whatever the outcome and whether or not the decision is enforceable, and the High Court has just held a small clinic to exactly that. It disputed a building job worth around £25,000 and ended up ordered to pay the adjudicator about £21,000 in fees, plus interest and his legal costs of £37,664.
The case is McLean v Winchester Medical Aesthetics Ltd [2026] EWHC 2941 (TCC), decided by Her Honour Judge Kelly, sitting as a High Court judge in the Technology and Construction Court in Leeds, on 13 November 2026. It was an application for summary judgment, which the adjudicator won, so this is a first instance decision on a fairly ordinary set of facts rather than new law.
What happened
Winchester Medical Aesthetics had building work done to its premises by a contractor, Archiproject. The contract was terminated in late 2024, and Winchester Medical complained about the quality of the work and wanted back everything it had paid, which was over £25,000. Their contract didn’t say how disputes would be resolved, so the statutory Scheme for Construction Contracts applied and gave either side the right to refer the dispute to adjudication under section 108 of the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996.
Winchester Medical started the adjudication itself in January 2025 and asked RIBA to nominate an adjudicator, and Mr McLean was appointed. He sent both parties his terms and conditions, and both signed and returned them. The terms charged his time at £324 an hour plus VAT, said he would be paid even if he couldn’t make a decision or if the decision wasn’t enforced, made both parties jointly and severally liable for his fees, and allowed him interest at 8% over base rate and his costs of chasing unpaid invoices.
He gave his decision in March 2025 and invoiced. Winchester Medical, which represented itself throughout, didn’t pay, and by the time the case reached court it had obtained an injunction stopping a winding up petition and had defended the claim on just about every ground available.
The clinic’s defences
Winchester Medical argued that the adjudicator had gone outside his jurisdiction and breached natural justice, that he wasn’t impartial and had manipulated the outcome so that the clinic would lose and he would be paid, that he should have visited the site, that his terms were unfair and unreasonable under the Unfair Contract Terms Act, that his hours were inflated, and that withdrawing an early payment discount was a penalty.
The judge rejected all of it, holding that complaints about jurisdiction and natural justice can matter when one party tries to enforce a decision against the other, but they have nothing to do with whether the adjudicator gets paid, as his terms entitled him to his fees whether or not the decision could be enforced. The Court of Appeal had already held in Steve Ward Services (UK) Ltd v Davies & Davies Associates Ltd [2022] EWCA Civ 153 that terms like these are normal and reasonable. Whether to hold a site visit is a procedural decision for the adjudicator alone. The allegation of bad faith had no evidence behind it, and the judge thought it had been made because the clinic didn’t like the decision.
Small and unrepresented businesses
The clinic said the terms were onerous and unusual, that they weren’t drawn to its attention, and that as a small company with no knowledge of construction or adjudication it was at a disadvantage. The judge said the terms were set out clearly at the start, the wording wasn’t complicated, and if the clinic needed help understanding them it could and should have taken legal advice. There was no inequality of bargaining power, as the clinic was free to refuse the appointment, withdraw its notice and start again, and the other party was a small business too. In the judge’s words, the fact that the clinic didn’t understand the law was “no defence”.
The clinic also thought it had an agreement that the “loser” would pay the adjudicator. That agreement was with the contractor, not with the adjudicator, so it made no difference to what the clinic owed him under his own terms.
The fees
The judge found the hourly rate and the hours reasonable. The adjudicator had kept timesheets, and his evidence was that both parties had sent him large amounts of disorganised and often irrelevant material, which he was obliged to read, as the Scheme requires an adjudicator to consider everything put to him. The clinic accepted at the hearing that the hours had been worked and argued only that it was unreasonable to spend so long on the contractor’s emails, without saying what would have been reasonable, which wasn’t enough. If you want to challenge an adjudicator’s fees, you need a positive case on why the time was excessive.
The clinic’s penalty argument was about an early payment discount; the adjudicator had offered to knock a third off if the fees were paid within a week, and withdrew the offer when they weren’t. The judge described that as a kind offer rather than a penalty.
The total came to £14,113.44 for the adjudication itself, £6,765.12 for his time chasing payment, interest at 8% over base rate (which matches the statutory rate under the Late Payment of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998), and his legal costs of £37,664.30, which the judge said were probably higher than they might have been largely because of the clinic’s “unmeritorious and wide-ranging submissions”.
If you’re thinking about adjudication
Adjudication is quick and usually much cheaper than going to court, but it isn’t free, and the adjudicator’s fees are normally shared or paid by whoever loses, depending on what the adjudicator decides between the parties. As far as the adjudicator is concerned, though, each of you is likely to be liable for the whole of his fees whatever happens, so read his terms before you sign them and ask what the process is likely to cost. If the amount in dispute is modest, it’s worth asking whether adjudication is the right route at all, or whether a negotiated settlement would leave you better off.
If you receive an adjudicator’s invoice and you think his decision was wrong, the answer is usually to pay the invoice and deal with the decision separately, as complaints about the decision itself won’t usually touch his fees. Fighting the invoice turned a fee of about £14,000 into a bill of nearly £60,000 here, before interest.
I don’t run construction disputes or adjudications myself; those go to my Nexa colleagues who handle building and construction disputes, and I can introduce you. I do draft and review the contracts behind building and fit-out work for owner-managed businesses. Get in touch if you need some help.
Written by Steven Mather, a business solicitor acting on company sales and purchases. This is general information about the law, not legal advice on your situation. Law correct as at .



