Steven Mather Solicitor
Steven MatherSolicitor
0116 3667 900

Writing

Can a buyer make you pay its legal costs if you pull out of the sale?

Steven Mather··5 min read

Can a buyer make you pay its legal costs if you pull out of the sale of your business? Only if you’ve agreed to it, as the normal position is that each side pays its own costs whether the deal completes or not, but some buyers put a clause in the heads of terms saying that if the seller withdraws, the seller pays the buyer’s legal, accounting and due diligence costs. If you sign heads of terms with that clause in it, it’s likely to be binding even though the rest of the heads of terms aren’t.

Most sellers assume heads of terms are just a non-binding summary of the deal, and for the most part they are. The price, the structure and the timetable can all change, and either side can walk away. But heads of terms usually contain a few clauses which are expressly binding, normally exclusivity, confidentiality and costs, and the costs clause is where this sort of term sits. I’ve written about heads of terms that turned out to be more binding than expected, and it’s worth reading the binding parts of yours as carefully as you’d read the sale agreement.

Why buyers ask for it

From the buyer’s side, it’s an understandable request. Due diligence and the first drafts of a sale agreement can easily cost a buyer tens of thousands of pounds, and a buyer who has spent that money and then sees the seller sell to someone else, or decide not to sell at all, has nothing to show for it. Exclusivity stops the seller talking to other buyers for a period, but it doesn’t stop the seller changing its mind. I’m not especially keen on exclusivity clauses when I’m acting for a seller, as they take away the seller’s options for weeks or months while the buyer decides whether to proceed, but I can see why a buyer wants one before it starts spending money.

So the buyer asks for its costs to be covered if the seller walks away. Some go further and ask for a fixed sum (a break fee) rather than the costs actually incurred.

Why I’d usually refuse it

These clauses are rare on owner-managed deals, and I’d never usually agree to one for a seller. Seller urgency always concerns me, particularly where the buyer thinks it can use that urgency to push the seller into terms like this. A seller who needs to sell quickly, perhaps for health reasons, a falling out between shareholders or simply because they’ve told their staff, is less likely to argue about a costs clause in a document that’s described as non-binding.

The risk to you as the seller is that the clause changes the balance of the negotiation. Once you know that walking away will cost you the buyer’s fees as well as your own, the buyer is in a stronger position when it comes back after due diligence asking for a lower price or tougher warranties. You might well accept terms you’d otherwise have refused, because the alternative is paying for both sides’ lawyers and still not having sold.

How to deal with it

When a buyer puts one of these clauses forward, my usual response is to ask for it to work both ways, so that if the buyer pulls out without a good reason, or tries to renegotiate the price at the last minute, the buyer pays the seller’s costs. That usually makes the clause go away, and how the buyer reacts tells you something about how much it really needed it.

If a buyer still insists, and you decide there’s a good commercial reason to accept it (perhaps because the buyer is the only realistic purchaser and won’t start due diligence without it), the clause can at least be made much fairer, and these are the points I’d look at.

The first is what counts as pulling out, as the clause should only apply if you decide not to proceed without a good reason. It shouldn’t apply if the buyer tries to reduce the price or change the terms after due diligence and you refuse, if the buyer doesn’t have its funding in place, if the buyer misses the timetable, or if something outside your control stops the deal, such as a landlord refusing consent to assign the lease.

The second is the amount, which should be capped at a figure you could afford to pay. The costs should be limited to reasonable, third party costs which the buyer has actually paid and can show invoices for, rather than a fixed sum or the time of the buyer’s own staff.

The third is timing, as the clause should end when the exclusivity period ends, so that if the deal drags on because the buyer is slow, you’re not still on the hook months later.

What to do now

Don’t simply sign heads of terms because you’ve been told they’re not binding, or because the buyer wants them back by the end of the week. Get advice before you sign, because once they’re signed the binding parts can’t be taken back and the non-binding parts set the starting point for everything that follows. Before you do, read the clauses which say they’re binding, and look for anything about costs, exclusivity or what happens if the deal doesn’t go ahead. If there’s a costs clause in favour of the buyer, ask why it’s there and whether the buyer will remove it; sometimes the honest answer is that it’s simply in their standard template.

If you’re under pressure to sign quickly, that’s when advice is most worth having. My page on heads of terms explains what they should cover and why I’d rather see them before they’re signed than after, as it’s much harder to take out a term you’ve already agreed to.

If you’re the buyer, it’s worth thinking about whether you really need the clause. A seller who refuses it isn’t necessarily planning to pull out, and a buyer who insists on it can start the deal with the seller wondering what else is going to be pushed through. Exclusivity, a sensible timetable and a seller who has been properly advised are usually better protection.

I act for sellers and buyers on business sales and purchases, from heads of terms through to completion. Get in touch if you need some help.

Written by Steven Mather, a business solicitor acting on company sales and purchases. This is general information about the law, not legal advice on your situation. Law correct as at .

Keep reading

More on getting a sale right

All writing

Swipe for more

Drop me a line

If you’re a business owner facing a legal problem, get in touch.

I’ll give you a steer and tell you whether I’m the right person for the job. If I’m not, I’ll say so and point you at someone who is.

Send me the detailsCall 0116 3667 900